You’re Overstating Your Capabilities

I just read a three paragraph explanation of the Hebrew word (cognate hrg) behind Zechariah 11:4’s “slaughter”. Upon completing them, a long felt thought of mine crystallized into language. The following paragraph is that thought.

Dearest Christian, like you, I believe that the claims in the Bible are intelligible to someone who only reads the Bible. Specifically, any reader will see that Paul wrote, “That Christ died for our sins, according to the scriptures, and that he was buried and that he was raised on the third day, according to the scriptures.” The reader, completely ignorant of history and any historical context will understand death, buried, raised, as well as the ordinal third, and day. Sins is a bit loaded, but even that, in this context has enough meaning that I agree anyone reading can “get the gist” of it. If anyone is reading or hearing the written word read to them, they will surely—even if completely ignorant of nearly everything—understand the concept of earlier writings or scriptures.

We agree.

But, Brother Saint, we do not agree if you persist in maintaining that the range of meaning of any and every word in the Bible books or any other books, can come to mind in anyone’s mind on this planet. Specifically, the triune god of the Bible does not gift people with some ability to know whether scriptures means the 39 canonical books of the Protestant OT or the 39+ books of the Catholic OT, including apocrypha writings.

That is an impossible problem of head knowledge that can only be solved by study, and study under able teachers—nothing to do with God (unless you want to offer that God provides the impulse to undertake such a course of study, especially in response to prayer on the topic).

We can’t walk through mountains, and we can’t guess every possible nuance of meaning, which oftentimes influences the overall meaning of the assertions of scripture. But we can tunnel through mountains and we can study what others who have written about the Bible have discovered.

In the end, friend, it’s just that you’re overstating your/our capabilities. Please don’t.

Leave a Reply